Fergie knows where to draw the line

TEAMtalk's Simon Wilkes feels Rafa Benitez's reaction to Javier Mascherano's recent red card shows just why he'll never win the Premier League.

Ferguson (l): Needless to say, he'll have the last laugh
Ferguson (l): Needless to say, he'll have the last laugh

Manchester United will again end the season with their hands on the Premier League trophy for one reason only - Sir Alex Ferguson.

The defending champions moved into pole position in the title race following Sunday's comprehensive 3-0 drubbing of 10-man Liverpool at Old Trafford.

Javier Mascherano's dismissal by referee Steve Bennett was a huge factor in the Red Devils' ultimate dominance of the game.

But I believe Rafa Benitez's reaction to the sending-off showed why he will never get his hands on England's ultimate prize.

The Spaniard is now in his fourth season at Anfield, and although he has delivered success on the European stage and in domestic cup competitions, Premier League glory has never been on Liverpool's horizon under his tenure.

This season they are in a fierce scrap with Merseyside rivals Everton just to secure fourth place and lie a whopping 14 points behind leaders United.

Benitez's problem, and he is not alone as Messrs Grant and Wenger also suffer from this, is that he does not know when to draw the line between defending his players - and giving them a good old-fashioned rollocking.

In recent weeks, Ashley Cole and Mascherano displayed a complete lack of respect for referees in shows of petulance which flew in the face of their 'role model' tags for youngsters up and down the country.

Both players have been widely condemned for their reactions to refereeing decisions - but even though Cole 'apologised' for his wild lunge on Alan Hutton he did it through gritted teeth with a smirk on his face.

Mascherano, meanwhile, has been backed by Benitez in his claim that he was simply asking Mr Bennett why he had been booked for a wild tackle on Paul Scholes before racing 20 yards to aggressively question a yellow card for Fernando Torres.

What both players fail to realise is that the game was screened to millions of fans around the globe, all of whom saw the Argentine international constantly chip away in Bennett's ear as well as wagging his finger in his direction.

I'm a West Brom fan so have no allegiance to any top-flight team, but one thing I know for sure is that Ferguson would have been seething if any of his players had acted in such a way.

Don't get me wrong, I'm aware Ferguson is no saint and is front of the queue when it comes to moaning about refereeing decisions.

But faced with a similar incident to the two in the spotlight here, the fiery Scot would've issued a curt 'it will be dealt with internally' - and it is this approach which ensures he commands total respect from his multi-million pound squad.

"The boy had already been booked and dissent is dissent, I feel he should not have got involved," was Ferguson's take on the flashpoint, while Benitez firmly pointed his finger at Bennett, saying: "Javier was sent off for dissent, but to be sent off for asking the official something is a surprise. He knows he made a mistake, but in a big game like this it is difficult to understand."

I'd have a lot more respect for Benitez if he just admitted Mascherano, who has been a revelation for the Reds this season, simply lost his head in the heat of the battle and ultimately cost his team a chance of victory.

Until that day comes, Ferguson will continue to have the last laugh.

Apply now for the Liverpool Rewards Credit Card

Your Comments

cleonard (Manchester United fan)

"To dragonkiller ... keep my mouth shut ? ... maybe you should use yours instead of another part of your body, read your post and try and make sense of it, it's not easy, I think you are trying to say United will be toast in two to four years and I will be looking to support another team, what do you think I am boy ? .... a scouser or what ? "

thegameplan (Liverpool fan)

"whoever wrote this "article" obviously did not hear fergies interview last week. amazing what some people see and what they do not! how scholes never got booked early on is beyond me. and then masch gets sent off for asking why torres got booked! typical from this ref - all he had to do was explain - but then again, its far better for him personally to get in the spotlight."

The_Pagey (Manchester United fan)

"Why do people keep banging on about Keane and Cantona? The reason the whole Mascherano affair happened is because there is a new drive to combat things like the Ashley Cole and Mascherano sending off happening. It was in the refs mind that he wouldn't take any grief and to be honest I'm surprised he hadn't spoken to Mascherano before the second card. I'm not sure stopping players speaking to the ref is a good idea but there is a clear difference between talking to the ref and being in the refs face in the way Mascherano was. We all know that there are players on most teams who can react to the refs decisions, Rooney, as someone pointed out, is one of them but most of us can see that Mascherano was pushing every point way too far. As for SAF defending his players, in most cases of a serious offence being committed by a United player, there is no comment made by SAF. He deals with it away from the media. What Rafa did was defend a player when it was blatantly obvious to all except the Liverpool fans that he had done wrong. Even if Rafa ripped the guy a new backside in the changing rooms, he made his own judgement look poor."

All comments on this story

The Liverpool Your Say main page
The Manchester Utd Your Say main page
The General Your Say main page

Character Count : 0/1900





Team News:

chrissmith_10 (Liverpool) : "...I think Barry would be a great signing. England international, left footed, versatile and arguably in the best years of his career at 27. People are saying he wouldn't bring anything to us, but just being English brings that extra motivation (think S..."   view full comment

   

Paper talk - Tigers to pounce for Vieri

Hull are lining up a shock £1million bid for Fiorentina striker Christian Vieri if the Tigers win promotion to the Premier League.

More from today's press

Summer strengthening key for United

There were many crucial moments in Manchester United's title defence - but TEAMtalk feels key summer signings were maybe the most significant.

Read today's Column

Gunnerz4lifeB (Arsenal) : "...Arsenal are to sign the new Brazilian talent Diogo. Currently at Sao Paulo side Portuguesa, Diogo has been monitored by Arsenal's scouting department for more than two years and the club have twice tried to sign him. In December, they lodged an infor..."   view full rumour

   
Related Team Pages

Don't miss these

LATEST PHOTOS FOOTY QUIZ WALLPAPERS
Jubilation at Ashton Gate after the final whistle
Image Image
Go to the Gallery Can you answer
all 10?
Liverpool Wallpaper
 More Stories

Top Searches