Curbs wins case against Hammers

Former West Ham boss Alan Curbishley has won his case for wrongful dismissal against the Hammers after claiming he had no option but to resign.

Curbishley: Won his case
Curbishley: Won his case

A Premier League manager's arbitration tribunal has upheld Curbishley's claim after he resigned at the start of last season following the sale of Anton Ferdinand and George McCartney to Sunderland against his wishes.

The tribunal will now assess the level of compensation West Ham must pay - a similar case brought by Kevin Keegan against Newcastle for constructive dismissal saw the Magpies ordered to pay £2million in damages plus £1.5million in legal costs.

Curbishley, 51, said he had had no option but to walk out in September last year after nearly two years in charge of the Hammers.

He said: "I am obviously delighted with this result. I very much enjoyed my time at West Ham and never wanted to leave, but on joining the club I insisted that my contract contained a clause confirming that I would have final say on the selection of players to be transferred to and from the club.

"The club completely ignored my contract when selling Anton Ferdinand, and when George McCartney was then sold, the club having given me assurances that no players would be leaving the club after the sale of Anton Ferdinand, I had no alternative but to resign.

"My authority and integrity were undermined and my position was made untenable. I now wish to put this entire matter behind me."

Curbishley quit the Hammers at the start of the season and launched a claim for wrongful dismissal after which the club launched a counter-claim relating to the cost of employing his successor Gianfranco Zola and his assistant Steve Clarke. The counter-claim has proved unsuccessful.

Richard Bevan, chief executive of the League Managers' Association, said the outcome demonstrated the need for clubs to respect contracts.

Bevan said: "Naturally we are delighted with the outcome for Alan but, at the same time, sorry that he wasn't able to continue at West Ham United, a club that has played such a prominent part in his professional career both as a player and manager.

"The findings of the tribunal demonstrate the critical importance of respecting contracts which need to set out the roles and responsibilities of the parties in clear and unequivocal terms."

Your Comments

nickellies (West Ham United fan)

"ibegyourpardew, he wouldn't have got near any of those jobs. Well, maybe Charlton. Managers need to wise up about finances but instead we get two cases won against the clubs. Curbishley and Keegan - the Cannon & Ball of football. "

IBegYourPardew (Charlton Athletic fan)

"Congrats Alan. How few are the men left in football with any integrity. It's a win for football. The only failing of course is the fact Curbs has missed out on the Newcastle, Sunderland, Spurs, Chelsea (!) and Charlton jobs because of this legal challenge. "

u_bizzle (West Ham United fan)

"Greedy little man. He doesn't need the money. The club he apparently loves needs to more than him. What a joke. We had to sell the players as a business or risk going under. "

STEVE Luxemborg (Aston Villa fan)

"Hammers really should sack thier legal team, they never seem to win anything, they really should have tried to reach agreement out of court. lets hope they can put all this behind them and it doesnt result in further sales."

magic_w (Manchester United fan)

"Why did they agree to a clause about who had the last say over who could leave the club in the first place? sounds like an error in judgment in the initial contract that was given to Curbs"

Jonno_Blue (Everton fan)

"If they had to sell them they had to sell them! You cant just hang on to all your players, dismissing the fact it will ruin you financially.

The players are the clubs assets not the managers. They should have had more consultation with him but I dont think they were deliberately trying to weaken the team they just had no choice."

pvb (Liverpool fan)

"the person i feel sorry for is little zola. he has somehow managed to keep the hammers together with very little money and despite losing so many of his top players. he has done really well but he badly needs to be backed with cash in january."

All comments on this story

The West Ham Your Say main page
The General Your Say main page

Character Count : 0/1900





Team News:

galboy : "...Disgusting result. Burnley hadn't won in 12 games and were ripe for the taking so what happens? We fold like a pack of cards. We should have picked up nothing less than 7 points in our last 3 games and yet we come away w..."   view full comment

Paper Talk: Hughes' Turkish delight

Mark Hughes is on the shortlist to become Turkey's new coach, while Kieron Dyer's West Ham nightmare will cost them close to £30million.

More from today's press

WC Famous Five - Rob Mullarkey

TEAMtalk Towers veteran Rob Mullarkey takes a trip down memory lane as he fondly remembers and describes his Famous Five World Cup moments.

Read today's Column

reza78 (Manchester United) : "...Manchester United will sell Vidic to Real Madrid in the summer with Karim Benzema coming to Old Trafford. Smalling will be the new star defender! Also, Frank Ribery will join Real and David Silva to United. ..."   view full rumour

   
Related Team Pages

Don't miss these

LATEST PHOTOS TT COLUMN COMPETITIONS
In the Telegraph Sport Michael Ballack says Arsenal are not good enough to win the title and tells Arsene Wenger to stop making excuses.
TEAMtalk column
Go to the Gallery WC Famous Five - Rob Mullarkey Free to enter!
 More Stories