Ireland woe highlights FIFA inertia

TEAMtalk's Jon Holmes feels FIFA's sluggish approach to the pursuit of football justice helped end the Republic of Ireland's World Cup dream.

Blatter: Not exactly all ears to new ideas
Blatter: Not exactly all ears to new ideas

Wednesday night's events in Paris reminded us once again that football remains an unfair sport.

William Gallas' goal, bundled in from close range at the Stade de France, ultimately sent Les Bleus to the World Cup at the expense of the Republic of Ireland.

And as Thierry Henry's left hand made a crucial assist in that decisive moment, the goal should not have stood.

That must be the case, whether or not Henry deliberately palmed the ball to gain an advantage, or made contact with it in that way by accident.

In this instance, and in countless examples down the years, the referee and his assistants did not make the right call to disallow the goal.

Martin Hansson and his Swedish colleagues have already been heavily criticised for their failure to spot the handball - or if they did in fact spot it, take action.

But pointing the finger and possibly punishing Henry or Hansson for their roles in the incident will not improve the sport we all love, however satisfying such an approach might be to some people.

Instead, the guardians of the game themselves must be called to account, for the pursuit of fairness in football is a FIFA ideal and it is high time the governing body stood by that principle and acted upon it.

The saying goes that if it ain't broke, don't fix it - and some may take this view with football, despite evidence to the contrary.

But if you agree that one of football's worst flaws was highlighted yet again on Wednesday night, then attempting a repair job must be a pressing issue.

So we turn to the International Football Association Board, who decide the game's laws.

The IFAB comprises eight members - four representing the UK Home Nations, and four nominated by FIFA. A two-thirds majority is needed to pass any major decisions affecting rules, and with the FIFA quartet traditionally voting as a block, the federation's appointees can hold sway.

In the past, the IFAB has made several significant alterations to the game - the implementation of the offside law, goalkeeper substitution, punishment for tackles from behind and more.

But on the issue of video technology, no evidence has yet been presented to the board to convince them to introduce it in even the most basic of guises.

They halted the last planned experiments in favour of Michel Platini's Europa League extra officials idea and recently shelved any further discussions on the use of technology until their AGM in March 2011.

Despite the successful implemenation of modern science in sports like tennis and rugby league, IFAB claim it would 'dehumanise' football and Sepp Blatter insisted last year that it was his responsibility to "maintain universality... (for) the 260million people directly involved in the game."

These reasons for inaction smack more of fear and possessiveness from football's leaders, rather than an enlightened approach to the quest for fair play.

FIFA should be assisting the inventors who want to find a solution to the problems we see every week, rather than sidelining them in the way British mathematician Paul Hawkins was dismissed.

At the least, his Hawkeye system warranted a worthwhile trial to assess how effective it could be in practice.

Hawkins told World Football Insider earlier this month: "If you're trying to run the biggest sporting event in the world, and the purpose of the event is to find out who the best football team in the world is, then you need to go to good efforts to ensure the officiating of that event is to a standard which puts the destiny as much as possible in the hands of the players, rather than the officials."

In the case of Henry's misdemeanour, you can read that last part literally - but the truth is FIFA's efforts have not been good and as a result, standards of fairness and justice in football remain below par in the beautiful game.

Your Comments

jgn_1982 (Aston Villa fan)

"jon....go back to school son, seriously....give it a rest"

dublintoffee (Everton fan)

"Travesty for football. FIFA got what it wanted. Ireland screwed over twice, unforgivable and I for one will not be tuning into the WC. "

tcraig37 (Chelsea fan)

"Why did Eduardo receive a suspension for diving in the champions league, and Henry received nothing for a handball? They are both forms of cheating and punishments should apply to both. You may reply with "his ban was recinded" but it was due to Arsenal proving that contact was made. Henry has already admitted he used his hand to control the ball, perhaps a FIFA official other than Platini could make an official statement..."

priceisright (Chelsea fan)

"wasn't fussed if france or ireland went through, but the game should never have been decided like this.

Henry should be banned, wans't the Eduardo incedent deemed " trying to deceive the ref"??

henry has even admitted it. and blamed the ref!!!

nothing will be done as France run world football.

Henry will be forever remembered as a cheat and con man, i used to think he was one of the good guys, the hanfd of frog will be remembered for years. maradona mk2"

defoe18 (Tottenham Hotspur fan)

"@RedBlanc (Arsenal fan)

"cant condone the handball, but funny thing is, if an irish player done the same thing, you guys would be over the moon. can anybody say hypocrit? "

You obviously can't, there's an "e" at the end you muppet. "

ChristianG (Liverpool fan)

"Backing up the Canadian Villain - I don't even think they would have to stop the game. I think they could carry on while it is reviewed. Then when the decision comes down teh ref is notified and makes his decision whether it be a penalty kick free-kick, yellow or red card."

davet82

"Two defenders offside, two touches of the ball by Henry in the space of a minute, four officials 'watching' the game... and nothing? Makes ya think...

I dont blame Henry either, I pity him that he had to resort to cheating to drag his team to the world cup. Its a shame. Something should be done but Platini onside I dont think anything can be done.

Also I have read comments about Home Nations love when England get beat, we do, but only fairly. Nobody from the UK or Ireland enjoyed watching Ronaldo winking or Simone rolling back to Argentina.

I think a reply in Wembley would be fair but lifes not fair. Its not a point in the league but a nations hopes and dreams of a World Cup that has been lost by cheating and then ignoring that cheating.

It sends out the message to kids cheat and you will win.

FIFA Fair Play"

weallluvwayne (Manchester United fan)

"omg i hate blatter so much its untrue!! why wont you just retire you w*nker!!!!"

Southendspursman (Tottenham Hotspur fan)

"it was unlucky but you should have not conceded in ireland. Keane should have scored that chance when he was one on one. AS you know in football if you dont take your chances you are going to lose. I find the irish were arrogant saying b4 the draw I hope we get greece since they are weak. What a stupid statement to make. Greece are in the finals beating the team that stopped engalnd getting a 100% record.

Go eat humble pie Ireland, and why should people care that it would have been duff, keanes givens etc last chane at a world cup. We can see the play every week in england.

Greece for the world cup. Otto is the king!"

All comments on this story

The General Your Say main page

Character Count : 0/1900





Team News:

GERRARD19 : "...WOW I celebrated that Portsmouth goal like they were my team and I beleive they have enough quality to survive with the players they have. I only watched the last ten minutes so dont know how well they played throughout ..."   view full comment

Paper Talk: Hughes' Turkish delight

Mark Hughes is on the shortlist to become Turkey's new coach, while Kieron Dyer's West Ham nightmare will cost them close to £30million.

More from today's press

WC Famous Five - Rob Mullarkey

TEAMtalk Towers veteran Rob Mullarkey takes a trip down memory lane as he fondly remembers and describes his Famous Five World Cup moments.

Read today's Column

reza78 (Manchester United) : "...Manchester United will sell Vidic to Real Madrid in the summer with Karim Benzema coming to Old Trafford. Smalling will be the new star defender! Also, Frank Ribery will join Real and David Silva to United. ..."   view full rumour

   

Don't miss these

LATEST PHOTOS TT COLUMN COMPETITIONS
In the Telegraph Sport Michael Ballack says Arsenal are not good enough to win the title and tells Arsene Wenger to stop making excuses.
TEAMtalk column
Go to the Gallery WC Famous Five - Rob Mullarkey Free to enter!
 More Stories