Top brass must change minds - SAF

Sir Alex Ferguson believes "every player and coach in the world" wants technology introduced to football - and Arsene Wenger agrees.

Ferguson: Wants to see technology introduced
Ferguson: Wants to see technology introduced

As the Republic of Ireland continue to seethe over their World Cup dream being wrecked by Thierry Henry's blatant handball at the Stade de France on Wednesday, a series of leading figures have called for match officials to be given more assistance in getting the big decisions right.

Ferguson has suffered himself recently, with Didier Drogba hauling Wes Brown down at Chelsea a fortnight ago as John Terry flicked in the only goal.

The Manchester United manager admits this week's incident is more serious given it marked the end of Ireland's chances of reaching next summer's finals in South Africa.

Yet he realises such arguments will continue until there is an attitude shift among the men who run the sport.

"It will never be solved unless the people who run the game change their minds," said Ferguson.

"It is not a matter of going round every player and coach in the world and asking their opinion because you would probably get the same one.

"We all think, as I do myself, that technology can play a part. It can help referees.

"But the stance is that they prefer human decision making. Until that changes, there is nothing you can do about it."

Whilst most of the debate emerging out of the Paris row has centred around Henry, and whether he should instantly have admitted an infringement, as a coach himself, Ferguson's initial reaction was one of sympathy for Ireland manager Giovanni Trapattoni, who almost masterminded one of the greatest nights in his adopted country's history.

"My thoughts were for Trapattoni," said Ferguson.

"He has prepared a team magnificently. It was a fantastic performance by them. He could not have asked for better.

"Then it was taken away from him.

"It happens. It has denied a couple of our players (John O'Shea and Darron Gibson) that great experience of playing in a World Cup finals. You can't get a better experience than that.

"But two weeks ago, Didier Drogba pulled down Wes Brown. There is not the same hullabaloo, which is quite right because this was a major incident.

"Ireland can't recover. But does the other incident cost Manchester United the league? It could very well. That is how important decision making can be."

The debate about video technology has always been about the amount of time it would take for decisions to be made and the effect it would have on the normal flow of a game.

Even in sports that have successfully embraced the concept - both codes of rugby and cricket - there is a time issue, although that can also heighten spectator excitement during the wait for a key decision to be made.

"Look at American football and the time they take with debatable decisions," said Ferguson.

"It might take three or four minutes, which allows the coach to talk to his players.

"I realise the fans are used to spending all day at the ground.

"The argument here is that football is a winter game and it would take too long for the referee to go across to a monitor.

"But sometimes a goalkeeper takes a minute to take a goal kick. The amount of (actual playing) time in a game of football is normally 65 minutes.

"It would only take a minute or so for the referee to walk across to a monitor - and he can be assisted by his assistants."

Arsenal boss Arsene Wenger agrees with Ferguson and believes it is wrong for football referees to go unsupported in clear-cut decisions such as Henry's handball.

"Football accepts that a billion people see it, one guy doesn't see it and it is the one who prevails. It cannot work," he told ArsenalTV.

"We cannot accept that an obvious decision is wrong because we do not want to give ourselves all the needed help we can have in the modern game.

"Being at the game, I saw the referee giving a goal knowing that something was wrong and that is really sad.

"He didn't see it, I can understand, the linesman didn't see it, but they couldn't get any help.

"In the end, he gave a goal, already knowing that it wasn't a goal. We cannot accept that in our sport and you have to do something about it."

Wenger believes there were clear indications - namely the reaction of the players - that Swedish referee Martin Hansson had made the wrong decision.

"For two reasons; first of all Henry didn't celebrate at the start, that gives an indication to the referee, but spontaneously 11 Irish players came to see the referee," added Wenger.

"That doesn't happen if it's not something obvious. You have two, three or four but not 11 and that convinced him to go and see the linesman as well and say 'Listen, I didn't see what happened, can you help me?'

"The linesman as well didn't see it, then what could help him is somebody outside, the fourth official."

Wenger is an advocate for video technology, so long as the referee remains in charge.

"In my opinion the referee should keep control of the game, but when he wants help he has that resource available," he said.

"We cannot sort out all the cases but we have to sort out as many cases as we can."

Frenchman Wenger was dissatisfied with the way his compatriots reached next summer's World Cup finals.

"For the sense of justice it is quite embarrassing to see," he said. "I think even France is embarrassed.

"We didn't play well at all and we won the game and won the qualification with a goal that was not a goal."

Your Comments

hillsman (Blackburn Rovers fan)

"shakermaker - FIFA will never embrace technology because referees & linesman will always provide them with a way to influence results to suit their own sinister motives."

Imrand (Manchester United fan)

"BAN HENRY FOR THE WORLD CUP! That will be great punishment for the CHEATER."

twobobsworth (Everton fan)

"If it smells like a cheat, wags its tail like a cheat, ITS A CHEAT! It not only robs Ireland's players of a once in a lifetime experience, it also guts their association of millions of dollars down the track. SHAME SHAME SHAME!!! "

swanseadevil (Swansea City fan)

"wow arsene wenger actually saw a key moment in a game that goes against his team, i'm amazed :O but fair play this man is becoming more and more respectable in my eyes every passing season"

dazzapom (Liverpool fan)

"I can't imagine "Every Player" wants the technology. Drogba would never get a game, he'd be suspended for the whole season from all his cheating!"

scotsman4life (Manchester United fan)

"I feel for Henry. I think he would take it all back if he could re-live the moment but its gone. Truth be told I think half the english team would have done the same in that position. He is a great player and yes did make a mistake but it is bound to happen unless the rules are changed. Get the reff to ask the player as mentioned by some posters and introduce technology. Maybe the other team could have one appeal to a video refferee each game?"

alicante (Bolton Wanderers fan)

"Henry should be banned from all games for 1 year as a example that deliberately misleading the ref is cheating & ihis dishonesty at the time of the incident for not owning up.I am all for techno in the game but there needs to be some real deterrent to the player.They are paid profesionals who should be monitored when playing & after the game & punished properly for any incidents where they broke the rules.The ref would not need to stop the game very often then to see a monitor.Time argument over. "

paddywhack (Chelsea fan)

"exactly mufc_1. It would take no time for a fifth official sitting in a box watching the broadcast to catch incidents like this. The ref can then communicate through their headset and ask what he seen on the monitor, and the fifth official helps with the call. I think all this talk of coached being allowed to challenge calls, much like they do in the NFL would be too disruptive. The referre should be only allowed to confer if he is not 100% sure of the call he is about to make."

mufc_1 (Manchester United fan)

"why can't a fourth official simply watch the game on a monitor like any normal spectator watching from home. Even if they wanted to maintain the position of a fourth official. They could appoint a so called "fifth official" to do this job. Their job could simply be to watch the match like any one of us who sit and watch super sunday at home. That way if there is a debatable decision the ref can quickly speak to this "fifth official" or "video ref" and ask him for a quick verdict. The referees already have speakers etc to communicate with linesman during the game, so i dont see what difference adding this extra official would do rather than enhance the game for all those involved. Let me know your thoughts everyone."

All comments on this story

The Arsenal Your Say main page
The Manchester Utd Your Say main page
The General Your Say main page

Character Count : 0/1900





Team News:

GERRARD19 : "...WOW I celebrated that Portsmouth goal like they were my team and I beleive they have enough quality to survive with the players they have. I only watched the last ten minutes so dont know how well they played throughout ..."   view full comment

Paper Talk: Hughes' Turkish delight

Mark Hughes is on the shortlist to become Turkey's new coach, while Kieron Dyer's West Ham nightmare will cost them close to £30million.

More from today's press

WC Famous Five - Rob Mullarkey

TEAMtalk Towers veteran Rob Mullarkey takes a trip down memory lane as he fondly remembers and describes his Famous Five World Cup moments.

Read today's Column

reza78 (Manchester United) : "...Manchester United will sell Vidic to Real Madrid in the summer with Karim Benzema coming to Old Trafford. Smalling will be the new star defender! Also, Frank Ribery will join Real and David Silva to United. ..."   view full rumour

   
Related Team Pages

Don't miss these

LATEST PHOTOS TT COLUMN COMPETITIONS
In the Telegraph Sport Michael Ballack says Arsenal are not good enough to win the title and tells Arsene Wenger to stop making excuses.
TEAMtalk column
Go to the Gallery WC Famous Five - Rob Mullarkey Free to enter!
 More Stories