Pogba, Milner & Valencia make combined Liverpool – Man Utd XI

Date published: Wednesday 12th October 2016 7:12

Milner, Pogba, Valencia: All in combined XI

Milner, Pogba, Valencia: All in combined XI

Paul Pogba, James Milner and Antonio Valencia all make the combined Liverpool-Manchester United XI, according to this season’s stats.

Monday night throws up one of the most hotly-contested fixtures in Premier League football as Liverpool welcome Manchester United to Anfield. The fixture itself routinely springs a surprise or two as the two teams go at it hammer and tong in pursuit of victory. With that in mind, WhoScored.com have used their unique rating system to formulate a combined XI of Liverpool and United players to make more than five Premier League appearances this season.

David De Gea (WhoScored.com Rating 6.48)

David De Gea will hope to quickly move on from his gaffe that cost United all three points against Stoke prior to the international break. The Spaniard’s weak parry off a deflected Glen Johnson shot into the path of Jonathan Walters proved to be costly, with Joe Allen capitilising to equalise.

Nevertheless, the goalkeeper remains one of the highest rated in football, with ‘shot stopping’ one of his statistically calculated WhoScored.com strengths, reinforced by the fact that only a handful of Premier League goalkeepers have made more saves from shots in the penalty area (11) than De Gea this season.

James Milner (7.45)

Alberto Moreno’s far from convincing start to the campaign in Liverpool’s 4-3 win at Arsenal saw him dropped from the starting XI and without sufficient back-up, Jurgen Klopp called on James Milner to fill the void at the back.

The former England international hasn’t disappointed, with a WhoScored.com rating of 7.45 among the best of all Liverpool players. He’s making the second most tackles per game (2.3) for Klopp’s side, while he is an effective attacking outlet having averaged 2.3 key passes per game – again, the second best of all Liverpool players – so far this season.

Daley Blind (7.69)

The general consensus at Manchester United was that Daley Blind would be phased out of Old Trafford in the summer, but the Dutchman has started six of seven Premier League fixtures under Jose Mourinho this season and has impressed. Indeed, only Ahmed Elmohamady (38) has won possession in the defensive third more times than Blind (33) in England’s top tier this term.

His versatility is a bonus for Mourinho, with two of his six league starts coming at left-back, but it’s his partnership with Eric Bailly that has earned the plaudits.

Eric Bailly (7.22)

combinedXILFCutd

Speaking of Bailly, it’s little shock to see the powerhouse Ivorian feature given Liverpool’s, at times, lacklustre approach to defending. Bailly, a summer arrival from Villarreal, has impressed in his own right following his switch, boasting the necessary attributes to succeed in the Premier League.

Forty three tackles and interceptions combined ranks fourth among defenders in the top flight of English football, reinforcing statistically calculated WhoScored.com strengths of ‘tackling’ and ‘ball interception’, while the 22-year-old ranks third for possession won in the defensive third (32). He’s rapidly endeared himself to United fans, with Monday’s trip to Anfield a true test of how far he’s come in such a short space of time after his transfer.

Antonio Valencia (7.35)

Similar to Blind, few United fans expected Antonio Valencia to establish himself as a first choice right-back upon Mourinho’s arrival, but that he has. The 31-year-old has started all seven league games under the Portuguese boss this season and has made the most tackles (21) of players yet to be dribbled past in the Premier League this season.

He’s hardly the perfect defender, but he’s proven to be an efficient performer in the United backline, with a willingness to press forward offering another dimension to the club’s attack, highlighted in that he has completed the second most dribbles per game (1.7) of all United players this term.

Jordan Henderson (7.40)

For all of Jordan Henderson’s critics, the new England captain has established himself as a key man under Jurgen Klopp, with the Liverpool captain averaging more passes per game (84.1) than any other Premier League player this term. It’s not just his ball retention qualities that stand out either, with Henderson having made the third most tackles (29) in England’s top tier.

The 26-year-old is a key man for the Reds and his influence in the middle of the park will again be vital when Manchester United make the short trip to Anfield on Monday.

Paul Pogba (7.70)

Paul Pogba reacts

Paul Pogba netted a stunning long-range drive to secure victory for France against the Netherlands on Monday night and he will hope to add to his one Premier League goal when domestic duties resume.

Pogba has made a notable return to United duties as his WhoScored.com rating (7.70) suggests, despite missing some big chances thus far. Only Stoke City’s Giannelli Imbula (3.5) is averaging more successful dribbles per game than Pogba (2.8) of all Premier League central midfielders this season, with the 23-year-old carrying the ball forward from deep with aplomb. He’ll need to maximise these qualities against Liverpool, particularly with Klopp implementing a high intensity approach.

Philippe Coutinho (7.81)

Philippe Coutinho set the standard high for a strong season on the opening weekend, with his long-range free kick in the 4-3 win over Arsenal setting the Reds on their way to victory. The Brazilian’s willingness to go for goal means he has had the second most shots (29) in the Premier League this season, while only a handful of players have been directly involved in more goals than Coutinho (5 – 3 goals, 2 assists).

He has, however, scored just one goal in six appearances against United, though it was a memorable solo strike and the Brazilian has that ability to change the game in an instant.

Roberto Firmino (7.76)

Firmino Liverpool

It may have taken time for Roberto Firmino to adjust to his new surroundings, but the flamboyant Brazilian has begun to show just why Liverpool spent big to secure his services from Hoffenheim. Klopp has quickly turned the player’s fortunes around and the Reds are benefitting, with Firmino’s WhoScored.com rating (7.76) among the best in the league.

With an eye for a pass, only Dusan Tadic (20) has played more key passes from open play than the 25-year-old (19) in the Premier League this term, and having scored three goals in his last three top-flight outings, Firmino will look to prolong his goalscoring form in Monday night’s heavyweight bout.

Sadio Mane (8.02)

Having gained the third best WhoScored.com rating (8.02) in the Premier League this season, Sadio Mane is quickly proving his worth on Merseyside. An average of 3.8 dribbles per game ranks among the top five this term, with the winger’s directness improving Liverpool’s fortunes in the final third.

The unpredictability to his play increases the club’s fluidity in front of goal, and opponents are struggling to contain the 24-year-old Senegal star, with Mane fouled an average of 2.5 times per game this season. Once he gains a head of steam, he’s a tough player to stop and Liverpool fans will be hoping he can continue his fine start to life for the Reds against United.

Zlatan Ibrahimovic (7.41)

Zlatan Ibrahimovic

Having confirmed his move to United over the summer, Zlatan Ibrahimovic seemed to adjust to the rigours of Premier League football seamlessly. While his form has dipped – Ibrahimovic has now failed to score in his last three league outings and has just one goal to his name in his last six competitive appearances for the club – the charismatic 35-year-old remains an effective focal point to United’s attack.

Only a handful of players have scored more top-flight goals than Ibrahimovic (4) this term, he ranks joint-third for clear-cut chances created (3) and is top for shots (38). Monday night represents the ideal chance for Ibrahimovic to get back among the goals following a poor run.

 

Ben McAleer

All statistics courtesy of WhoScored.com, where you can find yet more stats, including live in-game data and unique player and team ratings. You can follow all the scores, statistics, live player and team ratings with the new free-to-download WhoScored iOS app.

Related Articles

Your Say

Home Forums Pogba, Milner & Valencia make combined Liverpool – Man Utd XI

This topic contains 10 replies, has 7 voices, and was last updated by Manthistle Manthistle 1 month, 3 weeks ago.

Viewing 11 posts - 1 through 11 (of 11 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • #1262829
    Matthew Briggs
    Matthew Briggs
    Moderator

    Paul Pogba, James Milner and Antonio Valencia all make the combined Liverpool-Manchester United XI, according to this season’s stats.

    [See the full post at: Pogba, Milner & Valencia make combined Liverpool – Man Utd XI]

    #1262982
    killyboye
    killyboye
    Participant

    This is an abomination. Whoever in Teamtalk came up with this idea should be flogged, flayed, then hung, drawn and quartered!!! 😉

    #1262985

    mbone
    Participant

    Pogba ? hahahhaha the biggest waste of money in football history 🙂

    #1263015
    suarezsteeth
    suarezsteeth
    Participant

    Valencia over Clyne? Really? I think even United fans would admit you made a mistake there. Pogba’s in the team but Lallana isn’t. Laughable

    #1263051

    Paxman
    Participant

    Using WhoScored.com ratings is a joke. Lazy journalism at best

    #1263132
    clibo
    clibo
    Participant

    Get with the times – whoscored ratings are based on comprehensive data! Is there a better way to rank players?

    #1263144

    Paxman
    Participant

    Clibo – I am a data analyst the who scored website does not use comprehensive statistics, it uses a few, comprehensive would be in the hundreds.

    #1263153
    clibo
    clibo
    Participant

    hey pax!

    hundreds of statistics may be overkill? do you know which ‘few’ statistics are being used? Relative to those not being used, are they significantly wrong/biased?

    as a data analyst, how would you have ranked the best players to go into this team?

    #1263171

    Paxman
    Participant

    Clibo – They did a piece on the role of a data analyst within football on Soccer AM recently and they do in fact use hundreds of stats, I personally don’t work in football so can’t answer your question on the stats to use. I didn’t say the stats were wrong or biased, I just said they were not comprehensive.

    #1263231
    clibo
    clibo
    Participant

    i hear you. In my opinion, whoscored is pretty amazing in terms of what they do, i.e. football stats. i feel their ratings are fairly reliable.
    any ratings and rankng system is going to have an inherent level of opinion bias around it.

    i guess the stats are not black and white, but serves as a good platform to indirectly launch technical debates between fans!

    Personally, besides De Gea, the rest of the ManU players don’t belong there;) We all know Firmino should be the striker in stead of Zlatan who in turn should be replaced by Llalana. Zlatan and Pogba should be at the Harlem GlobeTrotters!

    #1263384
    Manthistle
    Manthistle
    Participant

    No Carrick?

Viewing 11 posts - 1 through 11 (of 11 total)

You must be logged in to reply this topic.