Dario Gradi’s side dominated from the off in Saturday’s League Two clash at Gresty Road but needed goals from Ashley Westwood and Tootle to cancel out second-half strikes from Craig Dawson and Kallum Higginbotham.
Calvin Zola netted for the home side after just two minutes but his effort was ruled out for offside. Minutes later Zola then dragged Joel Grant’s lay-off wide before Clayton Donaldson forced a fine save from Tom Heaton with a 25-yard effort.
Dale took the lead when Dawson drilled home Tom Kennedy’s 53rd-minute corner from six yards out.
However, Westwood restored parity when he rammed the ball home from the edge of the box in the 71st minute, only for Higginbotham to drill into the roof of the net to restore Dale’s advantage three minutes later.
But Tootle earned the Railwaymen a point when he hit home at the second attempt in the 77th minute.