Reply To: Scholes is prime examples to why great footballers don't make great pundits

#715980

Manthistle
Participant
  • :

Is this not the case with all pundits though? Has Carragher ever slated Gerrard even with his red card against Utd last season. I doubt it. Keown is biased towards Arsenal. Souness to Liverpool, Thompson towards Liverpool, Redknapp to anyone he has played for or his dad’s managed or his cousin played for. I’ve noticed that Mick Summerbee hasn’t been invited back for a while by Skysports because he was so biased towards City.

Scholes has friends at Utd so its understandable he wont criticise them but he never played or worked under LvG so has no problem in criticising him. To be fair Giggs is still there so you’d think he’d communicate with him albeit away from the cameras.