Jurgen and Neville

This topic contains 16 replies, has 9 voices, and was last updated by MrMakaveli MrMakaveli 7 years, 3 months ago.

Viewing 17 posts - 1 through 17 (of 17 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • #1381378
    Hightown hope
    Hightown hope
    Participant
    • :

    Very unlike Gary Neville to keep his mouth shut when Jurgen was interviewed post game last night. Whoever the Sky anchor and Carra asked all the questions and Neville just stood there. Shithouse. ..he could have buried last week’s disagreement but I reckon he was afraid of what Jurgen would say. As it happens what Neville said about Karius, I by and large agree with but he missed the chance to bury the hatchet last night. It looked weak

    #1381465
    Red Herring
    Red Herring
    Participant
    • :

    HH>> Yes, I was thinking exactly the same thing as I was watching it. Klopp had him on toast last week and he was scared that he’d be pumpernickel under the grill again.

    Germans, in general, are not renowned for their sense of humour (although these national stereotypes probably don’t stand up to a great deal of scrutiny). However, whether it was “off the cuff” or pre=planned, but his remark “The pundits, former players most of them, forgot completely how it felt when they got criticised. Especially the Neville brothers – the one who was the manager – he obviously should know that too much criticism never helps.” That was pure genius, worthy of Shankly, with the subtle hint that they are of such little significance to him that he doesn’t even know which one is which!

    #1381501

    CM
    Participant
    • :

    Was it pre planned and I still do not know what Neville did wrong, this is what Carragher said about the keeper

    This goalkeeper is yet to convince me in any game he’s played that he’s of the required standard. It’s early days but there needs to be a massive improvement. He hasn’t done anything in those game he played that’s impressed me.

    and

    This week defending across the Premier League has been absolutely embarrassing. My advice to Karius would be to shut up and do your job. Karius’ confidence is all over the place, he does the hokey-cokey when he comes out for the second goal and then he freezes.

    Yet Klopp took it out on Neville and turned it tribal. Klopp a few days later dropped Karius and confirmed it was because he did not play well. Also Neville did not retaliate to Karius comments, it was Carragher who told him to shut up.

    #1381507

    NotoriousBingo
    Participant
    • :

    Its not about Karius or Mignolet starting, its about making the situation so that we have competition for places, so both keepers actually improve.
    This is the first season I´ve witnessed with Mignolet in the team without the mistakes, its because Karius has pushed him to become a better keeper.
    Throwing silly arguments about Karius or Mignolet being bad keepers does nothing for us but sticking by them and pushing them to become better does.

    #1381516

    liverlad
    Participant
    • :

    Gary Neville is one of the best pundits.

    #1381573
    Red Herring
    Red Herring
    Participant
    • :

    How can Gary Neville be one of the best pundits when he lets his natural bias flavour most of the stuff he says. Did you hear him at half-time yesterday? Replaying some of the first-half “highlights” and someone from Everton crossed from their left towards Lukaku; but Klavan got to the ball first and made a good, but fairly regulation, centre-back clearance. So how dig Gary describe it? “Everton were unlucky there”.

    #1381594

    nine nine nine
    Moderator
    • :

    I agree with liverlad re Neville being the best pundit on TV and Neville is critical of all both clubs and players when it’s justified Inc United and their players too and given that Klopp dropped Karius which is the biggest criticism possible was Neville wrong?

    Also as CM rightly points out Carragher was just as critical if not more critical but Klopp ignored what Carrsgher had said seemingly wanting to turn it into a United v Liverpool clash.

    There was a Sunday Supplement Special on Sunday and Neville has plenty to say about his criticism and Klopp’s/ Liverpool’s reaction to it you can get it on Catch Up on Sky if anyone is interested.

    #1381609
    Red Herring
    Red Herring
    Participant
    • :

    …and can you recall him being “on the mike” in the Liverpool/Man Utd fixture earlier this season? Quite out of character, Man Utd actually started the game quite brightly and were on the front foot for approx. 10 minutes. Gary was obviously creaming his shreddies over this and was even beginning to make mini-version noises of when Torres scored against Barcelona. The fact that Liverpool then totally dominated the next 80 minutes took a long time to register with our Gaz and it was only in his post-match analysis when he realised that he’d look such an out of touch twat if he did not concede that Liverpool probably just edged it. Total t@sser in my mind.

    #1381666
    Red Herring
    Red Herring
    Participant
    • :

    999>> You just don’t get it do you? Neville’s “balance” only comes into play when it is so mind-blowingly obvious that adopting any other position would call his professional integrity into question.

    As regards the Karius issue, the point was not whether his performances warranted any media criticism or not. It was the fact that the bretheren were telling him to “keep his gob shut” when Karius was keeping a pre-booked 45 minute interview with Ian Ladyman. This topic was clearly going to arise and of course he had to give his reaction which was, certainly in my opinion, actually very cool, calm and collected.

    #1381678
    nediarb2
    nediarb2
    Participant
    • :

    I hated G Neville as a player, but I’ve been pleasantly surprised by him as a pundit. I don’t think he’s overly critical of us, as you would expect. Klopp has a good sense of humour, as he’s shown on numerous occasions, and he was being smart by making any criticism seem like a ManU LFC thing. Circle the wagons 😉

    #1381774
    MrMakaveli
    MrMakaveli
    Blocked
    • :

    I wasn’t too impressed with any of the comments made about Karius from anyone at Sky but I’m glad it was left as it’s less time that Karius is under the media spotlight. Mignolet is doing just fine for us so far, the defence looks more confident since the change back and now Karius gets to settle in, work hard and wait for his chance.

    As for Neville or Carra or whoever it is, the one constant is Sky. Murdoch loves to cultivate and sell drama. Not everything that’s said in post match discussions or MNF etc are the actual opinion of the ex-pro but a subject or angle that they have been instructed to broach.

    #1381780
    Hightown hope
    Hightown hope
    Participant
    • :

    Whether one agreeS with Nevilles assessment of Karius or not, he bottled it big time last night!

    #1381804
    Red Herring
    Red Herring
    Participant
    • :

    ….and he also showed an embarrassingly inept knowledge of the basic laws of the game when attempting to analyse whether Silva was offside for Sterling’s goal on Sunday. He started discussing whether Silva was interfering with Cech’s eyeline when the ball was kicked as opposed to when the ball reached the area where Cech would be engaging with it. This was total nonsense and he was getting confused with the basic offside law. Nobody was contesting whether Silva was in an “offside” position or not – it was clear to see by about 5 yards! The issue is whether Silva interfered in Cech’s ability to make the save at any time during the ball’s path towards goal; not just when the ball was kicked.

    I’m a bit intrigued as to why everyone seems to think he’s a good pundit. I can only assume that you’re taken in by the fact that his delivery is fairly confident and assured, but the substance doesn’t quite match up to the style.

    #1381816

    gingerlfc
    Participant
    • :

    Mignolet should continue in goals until either Karius has earned the shirt or Mignolet is so bad that we are left with no choice.
    Karius needs to up his standards and force his way into the team, not simply be given the shirt.
    Mignolet did pretty well last night. While not having to make any major saves he did what he had to very well with little fuss. He came rushing out of his box at the appropriate times to clean up and came to collect when needed.
    Let Karius earn the shirt through training and cup games.

    #1381948
    Hightown hope
    Hightown hope
    Participant
    • :

    I don’t think there is any doubt that Migs will in nets for the foreseeable future, with the likely exception of the FA Cup games. This is so obviously the right decision

    #1382020

    nine nine nine
    Moderator
    • :

    Red Herring, ha, ha , we all see things differently mate be a boring old football site if we didn’t.

    I couldn’t stand Neville as a player and wasn’t looking forward to him being a pundit but imo he does a very good job and is probably again imo the best there is.

    Have a look at what Garry Neville said on the Karius situation on the Sunday Supplement it’s still available on Sky it didn’t look like he was running away from anything on there.

    But it’s all yesterday’s fish and chip paper now buddy. Karius has been dropped by Klopp and I can’t see too much changing now certainly in the short to medium term time to move on and put it all to bed now. Cheers 999

    #1382146
    MrMakaveli
    MrMakaveli
    Blocked
    • :

    Me too, I cringed when I heard that Neville was going to be a pundit. As far as pundits go, he’s superior to most when talking about the game.

Viewing 17 posts - 1 through 17 (of 17 total)

You must be logged in to reply this topic.