Comparing Man Utd’s transfer targets to the club’s current crop

Zlatan Ibrahimovic & Raphael Varane: Could link up at United

Manchester United look set for another summer of heavy spending, this time under the leadership of Jose Mourinho. But how would their top targets improve on the men they could replace at Old Trafford?

In what seemed an eternity, Louis van Gaal’s sacking as Manchester United manager was confirmed on Monday night. In all honesty, the Dutchman had been a dead man walking since Christmas, with the football stagnant and the supporters rapidly losing faith in the Van Gaal philosophy.

But with Jose Mourinho coming in as his successor, looks at the potential signings the manager could make and how they compare to the current crop of United stars.


Defensive targets

John Stones


The Everton centre-back’s development was stunted due to a disappointing season for the Toffees and a lack of proper defensive coaching, but his stock is still high and he is still likely to command a fee of £45million. Manchester City are the frontrunners for Stones’ signature, though are expected to face competition from Manchester United. Mourinho tried to sign Stones during his time at Chelsea last summer and could move for the defender again. The youngster is far from the finished article – no outfield player committed more errors that led to an opposition goal than Stones (3) in the Premier League this season – but can be considered a star in the making.


Raphael Varane

Raphael Varane: On United's shopping list

Another whose form his dipped this season, Varane’s been forced to watch from the sidelines with injury hindering his improvement as a player. Given Sergio Ramos and Pepe’s renewed defensive partnership, the Frenchman’s been restricted to just 23 league starts due to injury, while a hamstring problem could rule him out of Euro 2016. Nevertheless, Varane is one United have wanted for some time and would further bolster one of the country’s strongest defences.


Stones & Varane vs Smalling & Blind

Chris Smalling: Enjoys playin with Daley Blind

Mourinho favours centre-backs who can play the ball out from the back rather than a no-nonsense type who looks to clear the danger at a whim.

In that regard, both Stones and Varane match the manager’s needs. Boasting respective 88.7% and 88.2% pass success rates in the Premier League and La Liga, both have better returns than Chris Smalling (82.4%) and Daley Blind (83.7%).

The former started the season brightly, but looks to have regressed in 2016, an own goal against Bournemouth and a sending off in the FA Cup final effectively summing up a downturn in form, while the latter is not a centre-back by trade.

Stones (1.4) and Varane (1.5) averaged fewer tackles per league game than Smalling (1.6) and Blind (2.7) this season, but then a centre-back should rely on tackling only as a last resort. They may cost a pretty penny, but Stones and Varane would be an upgrade on United’s defensive options at present.


Midfield targets

Nemanja Matic

Nemanja Matic: Linked with Man Utd move

Matic established himself as one of the finest defensive midfielders in England upon his return to Chelsea and played a starring role in the Blues’ title win in 2015. However, his form – like Chelsea’s – dipped while a lack of confidence saw his performance levels drop. That isn’t to say his ability has deserted him completely. Matic has made more tackles (213) than any other player in the last two Premier League seasons and when at his controlling best, the Serb is an incredibly difficult midfielder to find a way past.


Andre Gomes

A disappointing Valencia season ended on something of a high as Los Che successfully staved off relegation. Now, though, comes the unenviable task of retaining their prized assets, of which Andre Gomes is one.

The 22-year-old’s biggest asset is his ability to bring the ball forward from deep, a type of player United clearly lack. An average of 1.7 successful dribbles per league game was second only to Joao Cancelo (1.8) of all Valencia players last season, reinforcing Andre Gomes’ statistically calculated strength of ‘dribbling’. Oh, and there’s the fact of the matter he is represented by Jorge Mendes, who is the agent of – you guessed it – Mourinho.


Matic & Gomes vs Schneiderlin, Carrick & Schweinsteiger

Morgan Schneiderlin: Defeat a 'mental thing'

United at present don’t have a player capable of replicating the threat Gomes carries, so it’s impossible to compare the current players available to Mourinho, though the same cannot be said of Matic. The defensive qualities he brings to the action means he may come in as a possible partner for Schneiderlin who, after a hugely successful period at Southampton, failed to match the heights in his debut season at United.

Indeed, the Frenchman’s rating fell from 7.51 to 6.92 on the back of his move to Old Trafford, with a drop in form costing him his place in France’s Euro 2016 squad.

That isn’t to say Mourinho will get rid instantly, but rather move for Matic to bolster the squad. Matic has made more tackles and interceptions combined (352) than any other player in the last two Premier League seasons. Schneiderlin, by comparison, has made 304. With Mourinho favouring a 4-2-3-1 formation, he could call on both to shield the defence given the positional discipline of the pair.

Matic was also a tidier player on the ball, boasting a stronger pass success rate (88.1%) than Carrick (86.5%), while Schweinsteiger failed to have the desired effect following his arrival from Bayern.


Striker target

Zlatan Ibrahimovic

Zlatan Ibrahimovic: May not make move to England

The most likely arrival at this point in time comes in the form of Ibrahimovic.

The striker and Mourinho enjoyed a fine working relationship during their time at Inter and the enigmatic Swede would be keen to link up with the Portuguese boss once again.

His stats this season speak for themselves. Ibrahimovic’s rating was the third best in Europe’s top five leagues (8.29), while only Luis Suarez (40) netted more goals (38). His form for PSG saw him earn more man of the match awards (14) in the top five divisions of European football this term. Like a fine wine, Ibrahimovic is simply getting better with age.


Ibrahimovic vs Rashford

Marcus Rashford: Heading for England experience

If he signs this summer, Ibrahimovic will likely replace the emerging Marcus Rashford on the United attack line. Anthony Martial’s deployment on the left and Rooney’s decision to drop in midfield means it’s expected to be a straight shoot out for a starting spot between the experienced striker and the teenage frontman.

Rashford (31.3%) boasts the better conversion rate than Ibrahimovic (24.5%) and offers a different threat to the latter, with United’s current striking incumbent favouring to hang on to the shoulder of the last defender to make runs in behind rather than dropping deeper to bring team-mates into play, although there have been signs he has that side to his game.

This quality of Ibrahimovic’s game helped him end the season with 13 league assists compared to Rashford’s two, albeit in a somewhat easier league. When fit, the 34-year-old would be Mourinho’s starting striker, but Rashford brings a threat that Ibrahimovic can’t offer and vice versa. It’s tough to compare given their opposing style of play, but if goals are what is required, you can do much worse than call on the free-scoring Swede.


Ben McAleer


All statistics courtesy of, where you can find yet more stats, including live in-game data and unique player and team ratings. You can follow all the scores, statistics, live player and team ratings with the new free-to-download WhoScored iOS app.