Ref Watch

This topic contains 79 replies, has 13 voices, and was last updated by bluefen bluefen 1 year, 10 months ago.

Viewing 20 posts - 1 through 20 (of 80 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • #1190931
    bluefen
    bluefen
    Participant
    • :

    Andre Mariner
    (West Ham – Home)

    Not sure how West Ham’s left back stayed on the pitch after initial booking and then constant petty fouls on Sterling. Missed a supposed Aguero ‘elbow’. Other than that had a low-key game. His linesman/assistants didn’t seem to want a make a decision before he did.

    #1191024
    Lalunableu
    Lalunableu
    Participant
    • :

    Very poor, blew up with nolito thru on goal at stroke of half time. other than the infamous manure extra minutes against us, Owens winner, no ref plays on past the minimum as per the rules. Linesmen hopeless, aguero onside with a great move. Marrinerw Did nothing about persistent fouling, the shove on Silva was embarrassing as was the number 26 fouling sterling.
    Again dean’s idiotic performance last week has been ignored this and marriner missed penalties for both teams. Finally staring straight at aguero and Reid failed to give a foul for an elbow. Useless 2/10. Watch the fa clamp down and this joke comment he didn’t see it.

    #1191039
    bluefen
    bluefen
    Participant
    • :

    I forgot about the Nolito HT thing – that was ridiculous

    #1191042
    Lalunableu
    Lalunableu
    Participant
    • :

    Admittedly it’s worse in Europe and world cup, where they give a minimum of 5 mins. Then time waste, bring on subs and then still blow for full time exactly to the second of the end of five minutes. If we’d blown today marriner would have cost us 3 points. Forgot about dinos early yellow as well, what a joker.

    #1191096
    Adlab
    Adlab
    Participant
    • :

    Plus the West Ham defender should have had a second booking. He went on to cross for their goal.
    I notice how keen the press are to get Aguero banned. I would be amazed if he is not particularly with United next.

    #1191288

    goatistuta
    Participant
    • :

    The worst thing a ref can do is yellow the very first tackle of a game. Fernandinho wasn’t even bad, ridiculous to show a yellow for BUT he did. To then not send off their 26 for persistent fouling is, well, puzzling. Would we have been afforded a CHAT to say last chance??? No way!!! He crossed for their goal, irony. Ref was awful, let them hit us at every opportunity and that gave them confidence to do it more and more. Can’t believe he blew up with Nolito through on goal, come on eh, that’s not cricket!!! Was stood 5 yards from Aguero issue, gave nothing because there was nothing. You can put a spin on anything if you want BUT Aguero DID NOT make any contact with his head and when looking at footage he didn’t see him. That should be the end of it BUT with the ragoons crying we will see. All in all missed loads of pulling in the box and fouls and was poor, 3/10.

    #1191867
    Adlab
    Adlab
    Participant
    • :

    Score 3/10 and only because he played ONE good advantage.

    #1191909

    cityboy54
    Participant
    • :

    aguero will probally be banned,just in time for the derby you just know it

    #1192143

    Mancity Jim
    Moderator
    • :

    Thought their number 26 was very very lucky to stay on the pitch, overall a poor performance for me. Having seen the aguero incident it doesn’t look good. He could have gone easily for that. Let’s hope the ref is honest in his match report and says he saw it, and we can get away with one. Haven’t see the vids that show no contact, are they definite? A couple of things seem odd to me regarding Aguero and Reid. Firstly why did aguero react like he did, secondly why did Reid go off, at worst if their was contact it was a wrist not an elbow, I am struggling to see how that could have such an impact.

    #1192443

    Brian blue
    Participant
    • :

    Reid was haveing a nightmare Jim He was about to be substituted according to their manager, They hacked away at Auger Sterling and Silva and we got no protection from Ref All they got was a talk….probably on what a nice afternoon it was

    #1192473
    mcfc-psychology
    mcfc-psychology
    Participant
    • :

    For me, Reid went off the field to draw attention to what happened and coincidentally was due to be subbed for a striker to chase the game.

    I don’t think ‘contact’ should be what matters as the intent was there

    Anyone watching on TV see their player leave his studs in on Stones? Didn’t see any reference to it on MOTD, also thought it odd that they didn’t include a wrong offside decision when Aguero clear through to make it 3-0 in the ‘highlights’

    #1212504

    Mancity Jim
    Moderator
    • :

    United away, Clattenburg, pleasantly surprised by his fairness and leniency. 7/10

    #1212516
    Aguerooooooo
    Aguerooooooo
    Moderator
    • :

    I’ll go with a seven to Jim.He would of got an eight.
    If he had the balls to send Rooney off.

    #1212540
    Adlab
    Adlab
    Participant
    • :

    Decent performance,! And thats from me,!

    #1212606
    mcfc-psychology
    mcfc-psychology
    Participant
    • :

    Good to see he has learnt from the Sterling penalty for ‘back ball’ v Spurs last season…

    #1212615
    gjblues
    gjblues
    Participant
    • :

    Seven seems fair. Agree with Agueroooooo though, how did it take Rooney three bookable offences to actually get a yellow?

    #1212651
    bluefen
    bluefen
    Participant
    • :

    Got all his major decisions spot on – with the exception of Bravo (it should have been a pen and red) and not dealing with Rooney (he should have easily be booked twice on several occassions)

    #1214550
    Lalunableu
    Lalunableu
    Participant
    • :

    5/10, he’s still losing 2 points for the sterling decision. Rooney is becoming a joke, well past his best and being played by his club and England purely in past reputation. Hopefully this continues for Manu. Lol. Clattenwigs inconsistency will rear its head in his next game when he sends a keeper off for a perceived foul in which no contact was made. Fellaini should have seen red but as ever missed again, did anyone see the foul on otamendi as he tried to score?

    #1222164
    Aguerooooooo
    Aguerooooooo
    Moderator
    • :

    Home Vs Bournemouth 17/09

    Ref : Jonathan Moss

    #1223916
    mcfc-psychology
    mcfc-psychology
    Participant
    • :

    Hard to ‘watch’ this ‘ref’ since he appeared to turn up in Bournemouth’s kit!

Viewing 20 posts - 1 through 20 (of 80 total)

You must be logged in to reply this topic.