Ref Watch

This topic contains 79 replies, has 13 voices, and was last updated by bluefen bluefen 1 year, 10 months ago.

Viewing 20 posts - 21 through 40 (of 80 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • #1224012
    gjblues
    gjblues
    Participant
    • :

    4/10 at best. And that’s for actually allowing City’s four goals to stand. Seemed to give Bournemouth many ‘sympathy’ decisions, didn’t book their players when should have done and should have sent off their 15 in the same incident that he sent off Nolito – from where I was sat, it looked like their player also threw the head in retaliation.

    #1224300
    bluefen
    bluefen
    Participant
    • :

    Very quick to book Otomendi and was dying to send off Nolito (both decisions were correct) but like gables states there were at least 2 Bournemouth bookings in there

    Also why no injury time – 2 goals, around 4 subs and Boric was down injured for a good while – and he plays 3 mins – I thought there was going to be a least 5

    #1224303
    bluefen
    bluefen
    Participant
    • :

    in fact I think there was 6 subs

    #1224402
    Lalunableu
    Lalunableu
    Participant
    • :

    Good one on the kit, what a plonker and didn’t put on a black shirt at half time. Just seen the nolito incident, handbags at best. But no point arguing the decision, just why nolito why bother at 4-0 up. Otherwise agree with other posters he had nowt to do so 5/10. Poor kit, poor injury time and harsh sending off but unfortunately correct.

    #1238571
    Aguerooooooo
    Aguerooooooo
    Moderator
    • :

    Swansea away 24/09 – Referee: Neil Swarbrick

    #1267209
    Aguerooooooo
    Aguerooooooo
    Moderator
    • :

    Everton Home 15/10 – Referee: Michael Oliver

    (Everon have only lost one of their last eight games
    that MO has taken charge of)

    #1267287
    Adlab
    Adlab
    Participant
    • :

    Maybe we can redress that balance today!

    #1267308

    goatistuta
    Participant
    • :

    One of the weakest refs around, just seems to not quite understand a foul properly. He is never EVER consistent either which only adds to the frustrations of having him ref is.

    I’ll guarantee he will book a City player for a foul and then let an Everton player off for a worst one, guaranteed.

    #1267320
    Adlab
    Adlab
    Participant
    • :

    Tell me a good, consistent and fair ref? What happened to all the penalties for tugging in the area? Just Stoke v City then.

    #1267347

    goatistuta
    Participant
    • :

    To be honest, with knob head Kokarov around its a good job they eased off on that rule

    #1267374
    Aguerooooooo
    Aguerooooooo
    Moderator
    • :

    Tell me a good, consistent and fair ref? What happened to all the penalties for tugging in the area? Just Stoke v City then.

    Very good point Adlab.Mike Dean gave one the next week after he did the Stoke game.
    Can’t think of many others getting punnished for doing it.

    #1268409
    bluefen
    bluefen
    Participant
    • :

    I thought Oliver had a reasonable game yesterday (Everton at home) missed the obvious hack on sterling bit at least tried to let the game flow for both sides – couldn’t see the couple of earlier pen shouts but they looked hopefully best from my position – actual pens seemed correct

    #1268814
    Lalunableu
    Lalunableu
    Participant
    • :

    Other than a shocking challenge on sterling where the Everton player tried to do him, ref had a fine game. 8/10.

    #1268844
    Adlab
    Adlab
    Participant
    • :

    Ref ok 8/10

    #1269207
    Aguerooooooo
    Aguerooooooo
    Moderator
    • :

    Yeah 8/10 seems fair.

    #1269231

    Mancity Jim
    Moderator
    • :

    Yep agreed fellas

    #1345912
    Aguerooooooo
    Aguerooooooo
    Moderator
    • :

    City vs Chelsea Sat 03rd Dec 16

    Referee: Anthony Taylor
    Assistants: S Burt, A Nunn
    Fourth official: Mike Dean

    He’s not done a game with us in this season.Last game
    was the 2-2 home draw with Arsenal last May.

    #1347727
    bluefen
    bluefen
    Participant
    • :

    Absolutely garbage display from the ref… I often think it’s a ref having a bad game but today there were so many bad decisions against city in particular you have to question whether this is incompetence or something else… stopping the game for Hazard (when city were breaking) and then not for City (when Chelsea were breaking), I saw two clear handballs for penalties, the red card for Luis was so blatant, booking Otamendi for an over-agressive challenge (it was) but the same wasn’t issued for Chelsea (Willian, Costa).. no yellow card for Willian when blatently dived… utter rubbish 0/10

    #1348357
    Lalunableu
    Lalunableu
    Participant
    • :

    Can you give a minus score, appalling. Expect closed ranks by Monday though so don’t expect a sanction. I’ve seen this ref on other games and he seemed half decent. Perhaps he was over awed and the game was beyond him. His assistants were also no help and Dean is anti city and always will be. No excuses just hope he doesn’t ref another city game as I’ve never seen so many city players, even Silva wanting a word at the end.

    #1348384

    Mancity Jim
    Moderator
    • :

    To be honest I am strugling to understand how a ref can honestly make so many mistakes. Have to say for whatever reason I think the majority were intentional and he wanted Chelsea to win. Lost some faith in the game today. We know it happens the governance in the game is poor to non existent.

Viewing 20 posts - 21 through 40 (of 80 total)

You must be logged in to reply this topic.